Reviews
Part of Startup money comes in four kinds, not one lump sum
Startup budget: four kinds of spending inside one number and how to size your own
Startup budget explained: the four kinds of cost inside one number, the test for structural against chosen spending, and how to build a figure that is yours.
Two people can start the same business for wildly different amounts, and neither is wrong. The gap comes from what they own, what local suppliers charge, and which permissions their activity needs where they live.
Tolerance for rough-edged work at the start also matters. A figure copied off a website is useless to you.
What does travel between readers is the shape of the cost: which items are forced on you, which ones you chose and could postpone, and which ones arrive quietly after you thought the spending was finished. Learn the shape and you can price your own version in an afternoon of phone calls.
What to take away
- "Startup budget" is usually one number covering four different things.
- A budget tells you what it costs to be ready.
Four kinds of cost hide inside one word
The "startup budget" is usually one number covering four different things. They behave differently, so keeping them apart is the first useful move.
Four cost types in a startup budget
Permission
- What sits here
- Licenses, permits, insurance
- Sizing question
- What does my authority require?
- Avoidability
- Usually unavoidable
Capability
- What sits here
- Minimum tools and stock
- Sizing question
- What is the least I can own?
- Avoidability
- Usually unavoidable
Presentation
- What sits here
- Branding, website, packaging
- Sizing question
- Would a buyer refuse to pay?
- Avoidability
- Almost always deferrable
Carrying
- What sits here
- Rent, subscriptions, loan payments
- Sizing question
- How long can I pay if nothing sells?
- Avoidability
- Ends businesses
Four kinds of cost
| Cost type | What sits here | The question that sizes it |
|---|---|---|
| Permission | Registration, licenses, permits, required insurance, inspections | What does my local authority require for this exact activity, at this scale, at this address? |
| Capability | The minimum tools, equipment, vehicle, software or stock without which you cannot deliver at all | What is the least I can own and still hand over the thing I sold? |
| Presentation | Branding, website, packaging, photography, signage, printed material | Would a buyer refuse to pay without this, or does it only make me feel ready? |
| Carrying | What it costs to simply exist each month before customers arrive: rent, subscriptions, insurance renewals, loan payments, phone | How long can I pay this if nothing sells? |
Permission and capability costs are usually unavoidable. Presentation costs are almost always deferrable, and people spend there first because it is the most pleasant part. Carrying costs are the ones that end businesses, because they keep running whether or not the work does.
There is a fifth cost that never appears in a budget: your unpaid time before the first sale. It is real, it is often the largest single input, and pretending it is free is how people convince themselves a venture is working when it is quietly consuming a year.
Structural or chosen: a test that works
For every line on your list, ask one thing: if I removed this, could I still deliver what I sold?
Structural or chosen cost test
If I removed this, could I still deliver what I sold?
It is a choice; defer past first paying customer
It is structural; keep it in the budget
If the answer is no, it is structural. A licensed trade cannot be practiced without the license. A mobile service cannot run without transport. A food business cannot skip the health requirements of its jurisdiction.
If the answer is yes, it is a choice. Choices are not bad, but they should be made after you have evidence that someone wants to buy, not before. Anything you can defer past the first paying customer, defer.
The trap is that some structural costs disguise themselves as choices, and the disguise is expensive. Insurance a client requires in their contract is structural, even though nothing stops you trading without it. A payment method your buyers actually use is structural. A quality of finish below which the work gets rejected is structural.
Three questions that move the number more than everything else
Most of the variation between a small budget and a large one comes down to three forks.
Three questions that move the number
- Does the work need a dedicated place?
- Do you have to own the goods before you are paid?
- Does anyone need to approve you?
Does the work need a dedicated place?
Do you have to own the goods before you are paid?
Does anyone need to approve you?
The real cost of a small budget
This is the part most budget guides leave out. The cheapest business to start is almost always the most crowded, because a low barrier to entry is low for everyone.
If your idea needs almost no money, almost anyone can be your competitor next week.
The money you saved on equipment goes elsewhere. It pays for the effort of being found, discounting to win work you would rather have priced properly, and the time to build a reputation in a field where nobody can tell you apart.
That is not an argument against starting cheap. It is an argument for honesty about where the cost went, and a low-capital venture bets you can win on distribution, service, or specialization.
With no plan for any of those, a small budget has not removed the cost. It moved it where you were not looking, and the online business guide fully covers that bet, since online ventures are its extreme case.
The corollary is useful too. A slightly harder business to enter (one that needs a qualification, an awkward piece of equipment, a relationship with a supplier, or the patience to learn something tedious) often has fewer competitors and less price pressure. That difficulty is doing work for you.
Build a number that is actually yours
Nobody can give you a figure. You can produce one in an afternoon.
Build a number that is yours
- Write every line item and split by four types
- Get three real local quotes per item
- Mark forced, deferrable, or optional; add forced only
- Estimate monthly carrying cost and months covered
- Keep a reserve you refuse to spend on setup
- Write every line item you can think of, then split them into the four types above.
- For each one, get real local quotes. Three per item is enough to see a range. Suppliers, insurers, and licensing bodies will tell you their prices; second-hand markets tell you what used equipment goes for in your area.
- Mark each item forced, deferrable, or optional. Add up only the forced ones. That is your true entry cost.
- Estimate your carrying cost per month, then decide how many months of it you can cover without income. That number decides whether you can survive a slow start, and the profit model guide covers how payment timing changes the number of months you need.
- Keep a reserve you refuse to spend on setup. Almost every new venture meets one cost it did not predict, and the reserve is the difference between an annoyance and an ending.
Write the quotes down with the date and the supplier. Prices move, and in six months you will not remember which number came from where.
What a budget cannot tell you
A budget tells you what it costs to be ready. It says nothing at all about whether anyone will buy. Those are separate questions, and the second one is far more important.
Before you commit any of the money above, run a test that costs almost nothing. Offer the thing to real people at a real price and see if anyone says yes.
A sign-up, a deposit, a booked slot, or a signed quote is evidence. Compliments are not. The federal guidance on researching a market before you commit is a reasonable place to see what that research should establish.
If you cannot reach buyers cheaply during a test, adding equipment will not fix it. Distribution is the thing being tested, and it is the thing most budgets forget to fund.
Where to go next
Work through the pre-spend sequence in the startup budget checklist, see how the shape differs across business types in the worked examples, and use the framework to decide the order in which money should leave your account.
Common questions
Which of the four cost types catches people out?
Carrying costs. Permission and capability costs are researched because they are obvious, and presentation costs are enjoyable to spend on. Carrying costs are the ones that continue in a month with no sales, and they are what decides how long you get to keep trying.
How do I tell a structural cost from a chosen one?
Remove it on paper and ask whether you could still hand over what you sold. If the answer is no, it is structural. The trap is the chosen cost that is structural in disguise, such as cover a client insists on before booking you.
Can I skip the local quotes and use a published figure?
You can, and the figure will be wrong. What a venture costs depends on what you already own, what your suppliers charge, and what your activity needs where you live. Three calls per line item takes an afternoon and produces a number you can defend.
