Maintenance
Part of Ideas by skill: three trades up the hours-to-product ladder
Ideas by skill framework: place a skill by how buyers verify it
Ideas by skill framework: three moments a buyer can check your work, four verification positions and seven example skills placed on them.
The price a skill can hold depends less on the skill than on how the buyer can check it. A repair is judged on sight and compared on price. Advice may take a year to be judged, and the price then rests on what you can show beforehand.
Placing an idea on that scale takes three plain questions and one table. It also shows which change would let you charge more, and why that change is about what the buyer can see rather than about how good you have become.
What to take away
- Verification, not scarcity, is what makes a skill sellable. A rare skill nobody can assess is harder to sell than a common one anybody can.
- Buyers check at three momentsbefore paying, during the work, and after delivery.
- Where checking is impossible, buyers substitute proxies, and the price rests on the proxies you supply.
- Staging the work or attaching a deliverable usually moves an offer to a better position.
Three moments when a buyer can check you
A buyer can judge quality at only three moments, and each one asks something different of you. A skill that gives the buyer nothing at any of them is sold on trust alone.
Before paying. What can the buyer inspect that predicts the result? A sample, a portfolio, a license, a reference, a small paid trial. If nothing here exists, the sale rests entirely on trust and takes far longer.
During the work. Can the buyer tell whether it is going well while it is happening? Some work is visible as it proceeds. Some is opaque until it is finished, which changes the buyer's anxiety and therefore the way you should communicate.
After delivery. Can the buyer judge the result, and how long does that take? A repaired object is judged immediately, and the local service ventures guide covers how position and repetition, rather than skill, decide the economics of work like that. Advice may take a year to be judged, and sometimes never is.
Four positions and what each does to price
Answer three questions in plain words for the work you intend to sell. What could a buyer look at before paying that genuinely predicts the outcome? Will they see progress, or only the finished thing? How long after delivery will they know whether it worked?
Four verification positions
Position
- Verifiable throughout
- Sample and clear scope
- Verified late
- Prior work, staged scope
- Verified by proxy
- Credentials, references
- Barely verifiable
- Honest scope, no promises
What the sale needs
- Verifiable throughout
- Competition on price
- Verified late
- Better prices, longer sale
- Verified by proxy
- Price rests on proxies
- Barely verifiable
- Overclaiming most dangerous
Effect on price
- Verifiable throughout
- Verified late
- Verified by proxy
- Barely verifiable
| Position | Typical work | What the price rests on | What the buyer needs from you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Verifiable throughout | Repairs, making, cleaning, anything with a visible result | Price and reliability, compared easily | A sample and a clear scope |
| Verified late | Design, writing, building, most project work | Better prices are available, but the sale is longer | Prior work, a staged scope, visible progress |
| Verified by proxy | Advice, strategy, coaching, anything whose result depends on the client too | The proxies rather than the work | Credentials, track record, references, a named person |
| Barely verifiable | Anything where the outcome depends mostly on factors outside the work | A price that is hard to defend | Honest scope, and a refusal to promise outcomes |
Seven skills placed on the scale
Each skill below lands in one position once the three questions are answered. The placements are judgement calls from those answers, not fixed rules, because the same skill moves when the offer around it changes.
| Skill | Position | Why it lands there | First move toward a better position |
|---|---|---|---|
| House cleaning | Verifiable throughout | The buyer sees the result when it is done | Write a clear scope of rooms and tasks |
| Furniture repair | Verifiable throughout | A repaired piece is judged on sight | Photograph the piece before and after |
| Graphic design | Verified late | The buyer judges the result only once a draft exists | Split the job into concept, draft and final |
| Website building | Verified late | Problems often show only after the site is in use | Agree a staged scope with visible progress |
| Business coaching | Verified by proxy | The result depends on the client as well | Attach a written plan the client can check |
| Strategy advice | Verified by proxy | The buyer may wait a year to judge it | Attach a deliverable that exists or does not |
| A promise to grow a client's sales | Barely verifiable | The outcome depends mostly on factors outside the work | Sell the process and say what depends on the client |
The first two rows are compared on price and reliability. The design and website rows can earn better prices, but the sale is longer. The last three need proxies or a refusal to overpromise, so a beginner there needs a first paid piece of work before anything else.
Holding a price in each position
In the first position, the work sells itself once seen, so the effort goes into being seen and into being reliable. The competition is real and visible, and price and reliability decide it. Local service business cases reason through that decision one case at a time.
In the second, buyers commit before they can judge, so reduce what they risk. Stage the work, show progress, and define what is and is not included. The online business framework treats the same problem as how much trust a stranger must extend, which is the buyer's side of this row.
In the third, assessment focuses on proxies, not work, and the proxies must be real and current. If the field requires a license or registration, you must hold it; it is part of the offer, not paperwork. The SBA says most businesses need to file for the appropriate licenses and permits.
In the fourth, the honest move is to sell the process rather than the outcome, and to say plainly what depends on the client. Claims about results carry legal weight once published. Federal law says an advertisement must be truthful, not misleading, and the FTC's advertising rules for small businesses set out what a promised outcome commits you to.
Moving to a better-priced position
You can move. A late-verified service becomes verifiable throughout when you break it into stages a buyer can see, and reading the shape of the work helps find those stages. Advice becomes verifiable when it is attached to a deliverable that either exists or does not.
This is usually the single most valuable change available to a skilled person, because it shortens the sale, raises the price and reduces the arguing.
The move in the other direction happens by accident. A defined piece of work that slowly becomes ongoing availability drifts from the second position into the fourth, and the price stops being defensible.
What the price rule does not tell you
Whether there is demand. A perfectly verifiable skill with no buyers is not a business. The startup budget guide covers the other half of the question, which is how you will reach the buyers you find and what that costs.
A startup budget checklist helps decide where the first money should go once you know your position.
Common questions
Is a rare skill not an advantage?
Only when buyers can tell it is rare. Rarity that the buyer cannot perceive behaves exactly like an ordinary skill, and the money goes to whoever is easier to check.
Why does visible work end up competing on price?
Because the buyer can compare it on sight. When the result is easy to see, the differences that remain are price and reliability, so those are what decide the sale.
How do I sell something verified only by proxy with no track record?
Do a small paid piece of work for someone who will let you describe it, and build the proxy that way. Free work is worse than cheap work here, because a price is itself a signal.
Can I just describe my quality more persuasively?
Not durably. Description that outruns evidence produces disputes, refunds and, where outcomes are promised, claims you may have to defend.
